Wednesday , April 1 2020
Home / unitedstates / The Mueller report catalogs the faults of the Trump team

The Mueller report catalogs the faults of the Trump team


However, the document serves another purpose: a catalog of what it was and was not true in the 2016 campaign and the administration of Trump.

Many, however, have not led to legal proceedings, as the president or his communications staff told the American public, in press conferences, in interviews and in official statements.

Others were omission lies, or implied incorrect information initially given to the researchers and then corrected, sometimes with consequences, sometimes without. Except for the president's statements, Mueller often did not deepen the intention of a person, but exposed the facts he had discovered.

A comment in particular seems to capture how the president sees giving false statements to the press. Mueller said that during the effort to spread a lie about his participation in the Trump Tower's June 2016 news response, Trump told a group of reporters outside the White House: "It's a statement to the New York Times … This is not a statement at a high court of judges. "

How do we analyze the report

The CNN approach to analyze the report was as follows: whenever Mueller documented a false statement made to public or federal officials – Even if it was the same falsity that he said over and over again – it was counted. This includes lies to the researchers and the Congress, which represent the public. The CNN did not include efforts by the White House to lie with other administration officials, of which Mueller points out several cases.

The final portrait, written by Mueller, reveals eight major issues around which Trump and his associates pushed false stories, from their interactions with former FBI director James Comey to the negotiations. about a Trump Tower project in Moscow, in the face of the president's negative denial that American intelligence had discovered that the Russian government was involved in the piracy of the National Democratic Committee.

Sometimes, Mueller makes it cold, saying that a person claimed something "falsely." At other times, Mueller describes an assertion cascade – often by the president just to retreat later to say that "substantial evidence" contradicts affirmations. On a few occasions, Mueller could not determine the truth, but describes how at least one person in a group should have given false information.

In its analysis, CNN explained the cases in which Mueller wrote down several people who gave different versions of the events as a false statement each.

The analysis of CNN also had situations in which false information was shared, but Mueller did not always make it clear whether the person tried to give bad information. In a few cases, Mueller documented how some people had explanations about the information they shared.

In total, although he rarely uses the term, Mueller's effort may be the first comprehensive discovery of a federal investigator to document the lies to the American public through Trump's campaign and administration.

Trump Tower Project in Moscow

Donald Trump

What Donald Trump said:

Trump faced a questioning attack on Russia in the only press conference he gave during the presidential transition on January 11, 2017. Asked about his possible financial ties with Russia, Trump goes He replied: "I have no relationship with Russia. I do not have offers that could happen to Russia, because we have been away. And I have no loans with Russia." This gave the false impression that Trump never made any agreement with Russia, although he did so in 2016.

What the report said:

"Trump responded to questions (from the media) about possible connections with Russia denying any business involvement in Russia – even though the Trump Organization had followed a business project in Russia until June 2016."

Michael Cohen

What Michael Cohen said:

Trump's lawyer Michael Cohen repeatedly lied to the Trump Tower Moscow Congress and later pleaded guilty to false statements. Specifically, Cohen lied about his attempts to reach Kremlin spokesman Dmitry Peskov with the hope of achieving the government's approval for Trump branded real estate. On August 28, 2017, Cohen sent a letter to the Intelligence Committee of the House, who said: "I do not remember any response to my email or any other contact with me with Mr. Peskov or other Russian government officials on the proposal. "

What the report said:

"Each one of the previous representations to Cohen's two-page statement was false and misleading … Cohen recalled that he had received an answer to the email he sent to Russian government spokesman Dmitry Peskov, in particular he received a reply via email and had a follow-up telephone conversation with an English-speaking assistant in Peskov in mid-January 2016. "

Mueller discovered a systematic effort by Trump and his lawyer Cohen to mislead the public about the financial ties of Trump with Russia. The disappointment was extended for years and included lies to voters, the press, the congressional committees and the Mueller researchers. In total, Mueller called at least 30 lies or misleading statements about Trump Tower Moscow.

From the campaign, Trump publicly denied having trade links with Russia. He often repeated: "I have nothing to do with Russia," and said that he kept himself away from the Russian agreements.

But the Mueller report documented the objective of a lucrative organization in Moscow of the Trump organization. Cohen led the negotiations, which included direct contacts with Kremlin officials. Trump knew about the effort and extended until June 2016, well into the campaign.
The first details of the agreement came out in the middle of 2017. But protection continued until November 2018, when Cohen was found guilty of lying in Congress when the project was over and how much Trump knew it. For these crimes and others, Cohen goes to jail this spring.

The report was also highlighted at least 15 times that Trump deceived the public about this critical issue. Mueller even rebuked Trump for not "answering" directly to questions about the Moscow project in a written testimony he presented last year. Trump never accepted an interview in person.

Goodbye to come and rain

Donald Trump

What Donald Trump said:

In an interview with the New York Times on July 19, 2017, President Donald Trump wrongly denied that the director of James Comey was pushing in an individual conversation. The Times asked: "Would you step on other people in the room when you talked to Comey?
"No, no," said Trump.
"You actually had one with the one of Comey?"
Trump replied: "There is not much. I do not even remember."

What the report said:

Mueller discovered that "despite these negations, substantial evidence corroborates Comey's account."

Sarah Sanders

What Sarah Sanders said:

At a press conference on May 10, 2017, after the disappearance of Comey, deputy secretary of the White House, Sarah Sanders, made the decision to be falsely supported by FBI agents They did not trust their leader. "The FBI file had lost its trust in its director," he told the press gathered. A journalist retreated, citing information that most FBI agents supported Comey, but Sanders still responded, mistakenly: "Look, we've heard from many FBI members who say very different things," Mueller said.

What the report said:

"After the press conference, Sanders spoke with the president, who told him that he did a good job and did not point out inaccuracies in his comments. Sanders told this office that his reference to" countless members of the FBI "was a" slip of the language "

The Mueller report documents at least a dozen cases in which Trump and his associates lied or made false claims about the facts that surround Comey's trait. Sometimes, these misrepresentations were multiplied by attempts to control the damage, and the president and his staff spread them to Twitter, in interviews and in official statements of the White House.

Mueller documents how Trump was upset by the FBI investigation into Russia and the issues he considered that provoked the legitimacy of his election victory. At the outset, Trump asked Comey to dismiss her national security adviser, Flynn, and then dismissed Comey, who refused to promise her loyalty.

However, Mueller documented the president and the White House on several occasions about why he dismissed Comey and the circumstances that led to dismissal.

For example, Trump tweeted: "I never asked Comey to let flyNn investigate. Only Fake News will cover another lie of Comey!"

Actually, Trump had invited Comey to have dinner, asked for the loyalty of the director of the FBI and asked Comey about "leaving Flynn go", as his national security adviser was investigating.

Mueller was finally shown next to Comey's version of the story, after confirming it with several other sources, including the president's diary. "Despite these negations [from Trump], substantial evidence corroborates Comey's account, "wrote Mueller.

White House press secretaries, Sarah Sanders and Sean Spicer, as well as Trump lawyer, Marc Kasowitz, also boosted false versions of Comey-related events. Sanders Mueller admitted his negative statements to the press about Comey as the leader of the FBI were a "slip of the language" and said "in the heat of the moment."

Trump Tower meeting

Trump Lawyer

What Trump Lawyer said:

Donald Trump's personal lawyer, Jay Sekulow, in July 2017 denied Good Morning America, Meet the Press and CNN that the president was involved in writing the statement by Donald Trump Jr. about the meeting of Trump Tower, although Trump had dictated his statement. son emitted.

What the report said:

After the publication of the statement, "the president's personal adviser repeatedly and incorrectly denied that the president exercises any role in the drafting of the Trump Jr. statement," wrote Mueller. Trump's legal team, which included Sekulow, reversed what they told the press when they talked about what happened with the office of special lawyers.

"Several months later, the president's personal adviser declared in a private communication to the Office of the Special Council that" the president issued a brief but accurate answer to the New York Times article in name of his son, Donald Trump, Jr. "The president later told the press that it was" irrelevant "if he issued the statement and said:" It's a statement in the New York Times … This is not a statement to a high court of judges. "

Mueller found that the public statement of Donald Trump Jr. The Trump Tower meeting in June 2016 was the start of a coordinated effort to characterize the nature of the meeting incorrectly and to protect the president. Campaign leaders had hoped the meeting would include discussion about possible harmful information about Hillary Clinton.

The public response from the Trump team to the meeting was full of guidelines from the beginning, including at least nine cases of misrepresentation.

A spokesman for Trump's personal legal team, Mark Corallo, worked with the conservative news site Circa News to create a story to question whether the Trump Tower meeting was a configuration orchestrated by the Democratic agents, he pointed out Woman It was not.

Trump Jr. He published a statement in July 2017 incorrectly asserting that the meeting was mainly about Russian adoptions. Instead, the discussion focused on US sanctions against the Russians.

Jay Sekulow, Trump's personal lawyer, also promoted a false narrative. In several interviews, he said that Trump had not dictated the statement by Trump Jr. Trump's lawyers later admitted Mueller that Trump had dictated. Sanders also falsely told the press that Trump did not dictate the statement.

And, finally, Mueller points to one of the annoying "who was lying?" situations – leave an important question of the Russian survey still not resolved. Did you know that the candidate at that time Trump knew about the meeting in advance?

Cohen told prosecutors that he did, and – and Cohen had witnessed the conversation between Trump Jr. and his father, but Cohen noted that "he did not remember that Trump Jr. claimed that the meeting was related to Russia."

But Trump Jr. he told the Senate Judiciary Committee the opposite. He said he had not talked to his father in advance. President of the Trump campaign Manafort and son-in-law Jared Kushner, the rest of the meeting's assistants, supported this story when he talked to investigators and said they would not remind anyone to inform Trump of the meeting. Trump, in his written answers to Mueller's questions, said he did not have a "record" of the meeting in advance.

Mueller was not able to determine the truth.

Flynn calls with Kislyak

Michael Flynn

What Michael Flynn said:

On January 24, 2017, the first national security adviser, Michael Flynn, lied during an interview with FBI agents about his calls with Russian ambassador Sergey Kislyak. Flynn falsely denied asking Kislyak not to refuse the new US sanctions. Flynn resigned after the press reports revealed the calls, and later pleaded guilty to lie to the FBI.

What the report said:

"During the interview, which took place at the White House, Flynn falsely stated that he did not ask Kislyak that he would refrain from increasing the situation in response to the sanctions imposed against Russia by the" # 39; Obama ".

KT McFarland

What KT McFarland said:

Michael Flynn's deputy, KT McFarland, provided false information to Washington Post columnist David Ignatius on Flynn calls with Sergey Kislyak. He said that the calls took place before the new sanctions were announced and that there were no sanctions. McFarland was not cited in the following article personally, but it appeared as a "Trump officer", according to Mueller's report.

What the report said:

"Flynn directed McFarland to call the Washington Post columnist and inform him that there was no discussion about sanctions. McFarland recalled that Flynn said words:" I want to kill history. "McFarland made the call while Flynn He had asked, even though he knew he was providing false information. "

The report gives birth to one of the first episodes of the investigation: the consequences of Flynn phone calls with the Russian ambassador. Mueller identified at least seven lies and false claims of five senior White House charges on the incident.

The story of the cover was that Flynn was in contact with the then Russian ambassador, Sergey Kislyak, during the transition, but never spoke of sanctions. Soon it came out that Flynn worked with Kislyak to smash the Russian response The sanctions imposed by the Obama administration to punish the Kremlin to interfere in the 2016 elections.
The Mueller report detailed how Flynn repeatedly lied agents of the FBI on White House grounds when he was interviewed in January 2017. This eventually led to his resignation and criminal conviction to make false statements. Later he became one of the carriers of Mueller's tent.
The report also set out how Flynn lied other people to the White House. Vice President Mike Pence, former Chief of Staff Reince Priebus, and Spicer repeated the lies of Flynn on national television and "deceived without realizing the American public," according to the report.
While officials were in the dark, Flynn's deputy, KT McFarland, knew the most complete story. Even so, he called a prominent journalist and falsely denied that Flynn was discussing sanctions.

Additional contacts with the Russians

Additional contacts with the Russians

Jared Kushner

What Jared Kushner and Avi Berkowitz said:

Trump's son, Jared Kushner, who is now a senior White House advisor, met with an important Russian government banker in December 2016. When Mueller's researchers asked about this meeting, Kushner claimed no one of the transition team prepared for the meeting.

What the report said:

"Kushner declared in an interview that he was not prepared for the meeting and that no one in the transition team even did a Google search on behalf of Gorkov … (Kushner Avi's personal assistant) Berkowitz, on the other hand, declared to the Office that he had searched for the name of Gorkov and told Kushner that Gorkov seemed to be a banker. "

The false narration of Team Trump began two days after being elected. Hope Hicks, his transition spokesman who later worked at the White House, said in two press interviews that "there was no communication between the campaign and no foreign entity during the campaign."
It only took a few weeks for this narrative to be launched. Mueller's report set out the amplitude of these contacts, with more than 100 pages detailing the numerous meetings, phone calls, emails, text messages and other communications between Trump's partners and the Russians.

The report examined how several prominent Trump allies lied or made erroneous claims to researchers about their contacts with Russians, in addition to the episodes already described above.

There is Kushner, who told Mueller that nothing was being prepared for a meeting with a Russian banker, although his personal assistant said they used Google to find information about him.. There are also Erik Prince, Trump donor and Blackwater founder, that statements to Congress and the press were subject to the report, which revealed that his meeting in the Seychelles with another Russian banker was very choreographed and I did not have a random encounter.

However, in the report, Mueller recognizes that some members of the Trump campaign prevented their efforts to destroy all the advantages in investigating possible coordination with Russia, and that there could still be more to to learn.

Attempts to shoot Mueller

Features of a special advisor

The White House

What the White House said:

In June 2017, President Donald Trump issued a statement to the press secretary, Sarah Sanders, of providing the press, stating that Trump had no "intention" to shoot a specialist lawyer Robert Mueller. However, on the same day, his lawyers contacted the Mueller office to indicate their concerns about ethics and, shortly after, Trump told his White House lawyer that he would withdraw Mueller from his duties .

What the report said:

"A threshold question is whether the president, in fact, directed McGahn to remove the special advice. After the news organizations reported that in June 2017 the president had ordered McGahn that the special adviser would withdraw, The president publicly discussed these accounts … However, the evidence supports the conclusion that the president went further and that, in fact, he directed McGahn to call Rosenstein for the special adviser to withdraw. "

On two occasions, Mueller explained how Trump tried to hide the episode where he had told the White House minister McGahn gave him the research of Mueller.

Early in 2018, news organizations were reporting that Trump had ordered McGahn to withdraw the special advice. In short, Mueller investigated this as part of his investigation into whether the president hindered justice.

Once the story broke, Trump rejected it, calling him "false news, people False news "

McGahn told Mueller the truth, The report was found, and Mueller certified that McGahn had "no reason to lie or exaggerate considering his position at the White House."

Presidential indulgences

Donald Trump

What Donald Trump said:

Speaking to journalists at the White House on June 8, 2018, Trump said that he was not considering indults for any person related to the investigation of Russia. "I have not even thought about that," he said, "I have not thought of anything. It is definitely too early to think about it." Even so, Mueller documents how Cohen was given the opposite impression in multiple conversations with the president's lawyers.

What the report said:

The report does not say in a direct way what the president's conscience was about these conversations, although Mueller exhibits a series of evidence detailing the ways in which Cohen had the impression that forgiveness was possible. Mueller points out that Cohen "remembered speaking with the president's personal advice about pardons after searching for his house and office," in April 2018, two months before Trump's comments.

Mueller adds: "Cohen understood from this conversation and previous conversations about forgiveness with the personal adviser of the president who, while remaining in the message, the president took care of him, either through forgiveness or to close the investigation. "

Trump's prospect of using his presidential powers of forgiveness to protect his allies did not come true during the two years of the investigation, but he always made bubbles on the surface.

Both public and private, Trump and his personal lawyer, Rudy Giuliani, repeatedly refused to finally dismiss forgiveness by Flynn, Manafort and for a brief period of time, including Cohen. The report identifies at least two cases in which the White House gave bad information to the public about the state of these conversations, denying that the topic of indultation had been raised.
These statements and the backchannel speak among lawyers about how "Trump would" occupy people who did not cooperate with Mueller, who joined the obstruction investigation. Mueller concluded that Trump "intended to encourage Manafort not to cooperate with the government" and that Trump wanted Manafort "to believe he could receive a pardon."
Everything came at a critical moment. Manafort was thinking of an agreement with which he ended up with the Mueller team. But while supposedly aiding the investigation, Manafort lied about some issues at the center of the investigation about possible coordination with Russia, and prosecutors later said it was not a lot of help.

In spite of the public suggestions, Trump did not grant any pardon to any of the defendants of Mueller. Manafort arrived last week in a federal prison in Pennsylvania and is scheduled for publication in 2024.

Russian Hacks and WikiLeaks

Russian hackers and Wikileaks

Donald Trump

What Donald Trump said:

In an interview with Fox News on December 11, 2016, Trump falsely stated that US intelligence agencies did not know who was responsible for the attacks related to the elections against the Democrats. He said: "They have no idea if it is Russia or China or somebody. It could be someone sitting on a bed somewhere. I mean, they have no idea." Trump said this, although the US intelligence community had already publicly blamed the Russian government for hacks.

What the report said:

The report describes how the US government publicly blamed Russia for some hacks two months before Trump's comments. The report also notes that Trump said this shortly after "the press reported that US intelligence agencies had concluded that Russia interfered in last month's presidential elections to promote the candidacy of Donald Trump to the White House ". Public report of US information agencies on Russian interference.

Despite the overwhelming evidence, which was reinforced by the report, Trump himself never said unequivocally that he accepts that the Russian government interfered in the 2016 elections, pirated the Democrats and tried to give an impulse Politician in his campaign.

Mueller called it the report. He noted that, despite public statements from US news agencies, Trump said they had "no idea if it's Russia," which made piracy. The report concludes, once and for all, that Russia was introduced "systematically and widely".
Trump has publicly questioned or dismissed these conclusions about Russian piracy many times, even at the Helsinki summit, alongside Russian President Vladimir Putin.
The report also describes how Jerome Corsi, a conservative and theoretical conspiracy author with links to Trump's orbit, provided bad information in his interviews with researchers. (Mueller said that he "found little corroboration" for the statements by Corsi about what made the day in which the tape "Access Hollywood" emerged, showing that Trump talked vulgarly about women.) The year In the past, Corsi said that Mueller offered him a claim to lie. , but says he rejected this agreement, he has kept his innocence and has not been accused by Mueller.
Trump and his allies have danced around the issue of Russian intervention for two more years. They have minimized and overshadowed the impact of the Russian operation and arose with WikiLeaks, the anti-secret group that published many of the pirated message messages. The report casts doubt on the important role that Russia has played in the 2016 elections.

Other probabilities and purposes

The Mueller report also documents a lie about money payments made to women alleging that they had problems with Trump, as well as a false statement to the public About the former consultant for the Trump campaign, Carter Page.

In a case that Mueller cited, Cohen told the public in February 2018 that Trump was not "party" of money payments. But Cohen had talked to them with Trump.
These false statements became part of the statement of culpability of Cohen in 2018 for related crimes in a case brought by federal prosecutors in New York.
In another example of lies at a time of scrutiny, Mueller wrote that the Trump campaign told reporters that Carter Page had no "role" in his organization. The date was September 23, 2016 and Yahoo! News reported that Page was under investigation to communicate with senior Russian officials about US policy. That same day, campaign staff members, Jason Miller, Steve Bannon and Stephen Miller, discussed email plans to eliminate the campaign's page, Mueller said, and was removed next.

Sam Fossum of CNN, Ellie Kaufman, Caroline Kelly, Holmes Lybrand, Nicky Robertson, Brian Rokus, Me Steck and Tal Yellin contributed to this report.

Source link